Colts Neck Mansion Killings
Did greed drive Paul Caneiro to murder his own brother and family?
4.4 (14)
51 mins
Explore the close bond between Keith and Paul Caneiro and how family business tensions erupted Discover how Paul’s betrayal led to the brutal deaths of Keith, his wife Jennifer, and their children Jesse and Sophia. Learn about the ongoing investigation uncovering evidence from emails, fire scenes, and forensic clues linking Paul to the murders.
Ep 1:
Smoke Over Colts Neck
A wealthy family is found murdered as their mansion burns, and a second fire miles away hints this tragedy is far from a coincidence.
Ep 2:
Blood Between Brothers
Two inseparable brothers built empires together, but a bitter money dispute and damning forensic clues reveal how far one may have gone.
Ep 3:
The Brother in Custody
Paul Caneiro is charged with murdering his brother's entire family, as prosecutors unveil a chilling financial motive behind the massacre.
Ep 4:
Behind the Mansion Gates
The victims come into focus as loved ones, while investigators reconstruct the brutal, calculated night of shootings, stabbings, and fire.
Ep 5:
Justice Still Waiting
Seven years later, Paul Caneiro still awaits trial as the community, evidence, and unanswered questions linger over Colts Neck's darkest night.
Discussions (10)
Reid
Level 7 · 6 mo agoHe set his own house on fire to play the victim lol
Ralph
Level 8 · 7 mo agoThis is clearly not true. Wealth doesn't prevent violence. Domestic homicide happens in every zip code.
Wilson
Level 6 · 7 mo agoMost people just hire a lawyer when a partnership goes south. Paul decided to burn down two mansions and wipe out a bloodline to avoid an audit. Talk about overcompensating for a bad fiscal quarter.
