The Au Pair Affair Murders

Why did Brendan Banfield and the au pair murder his wife?

4.1 (33)

72 mins

Explore the disturbing case of Brendan Banfield, a federal investigator accused of orchestrating a calculated and violent plot against his wife, Christine Banfield. Discover how their young au pair, and Joseph Ryan became entangled in a scheme involving deception, control, and deadly consequences.

Ep 1:

The Twisted Fantasy Behind the Murders

An IRS agent, his young au pair, and a fetish website collide in a Virginia suburb where prosecutors say a warped fantasy led to two brutal murders.

Ep 2:

The Morning the Fairy Tale Shattered

Body camera footage and frantic 911 calls reveal the chaotic minutes when a staged home invasion allegedly collapsed into confession, and the secret affair that fueled it all.

Ep 3:

Unraveling the Home Invasion Lie

Investigators dig beneath a hero narrative, uncovering suspicious gun range visits, a mysterious passport, and forensic clues suggesting the crime scene was carefully staged.

Ep 4:

Betrayal on the Witness Stand

The au pair turned star witness takes the stand, her flat testimony and jailhouse letters exposing a fractured trauma bond between manipulation and betrayal.

Ep 5:

What the Body Cannot Hide

Forensic evidence contradicts the defense's story of a home invasion, while a four-year-old's fractured memories reveal the devastating toll on the family's youngest victim.

Ep 6:

Guilty: Inside a Family Destroyed

After hours of deliberation, a jury delivers its verdict, and experts examine the chilling psychology of familicide behind Brendan Banfield's alleged crimes.

Ep 7:

The Unanswered Horrors of Herndon

As the case closes, haunting questions remain about missed chances, hidden motives, and how a picture-perfect suburban family hid such calculated darkness.

Download the App

And Listen to Full Podcast