
How did the police execute the wrong Carlos for murder?
4.7 (14)
61 mins
Explore Carlos DeLuna’s early life and the systemic challenges he faced. Discover how investigative flaws and weak defense led to his wrongful conviction. Learn about the later reinvestigation that revealed the real killer and DeLuna’s innocence.
Ep 1:
A Gas Station, A Scream, A Suspect
On a chilly February night in Corpus Christi, a gas station clerk's frantic 911 call ends in murder, and a barefoot man found hiding nearby becomes the prime suspect.
Ep 2:
The Other Carlos and a Broken Mind
DeLuna insists another man named Carlos committed the murder, while psychiatrists probe his claims of memory loss—setting up a mystery the prosecution dismisses as fantasy.
Ep 3:
Trial by Resources: Guilty by Design
With a resource-starved defense and a relentless prosecution, DeLuna's fate is sealed as jurors weigh flimsy identification evidence against his troubled past—and choose death.
Ep 4:
The Needle Falls, The Truth Emerges
As DeLuna's final hours unfold, a decade-long Columbia Law investigation begins unraveling stunning evidence that Texas may have executed the wrong man.
Ep 5:
Cracks in the System
A deep dive into the police, defense, and prosecutorial failures that let a flawed case march all the way to execution—exposing a justice system that failed everyone.
Ep 6:
What Justice Never Answered
In this closing reflection, unanswered questions about guilt, innocence, and irreversible punishment linger, forcing a reckoning with what true justice demands.
Ruth
Level 2 · 9 mo agoHernández was bragging that the other Carlos took the fall. That is actual sociopathic behavior.
Emily
Level 8 · 8 mo agoHearing Hernández bragged about his namesake taking the fall makes me sick to my stomach! 😠
Marcus
Level 4 · 9 mo agoHernández bragging his namesake took the fall is mental! Fella had 39 arrests yet the clowns called him a phantom. Proper shite that an innocent lad got the needle while the real killer walked.