Killer of Long Island
Can a Good Samaritan be suspected of killings on Oak Island?
4.5 (28)
39 mins
Discover the eerie silence of Oak Beach, where a young woman’s disappearance reveals a series of haunting secrets. Explore how Dr. Peter Hackett, an emergency surgeon, got caught in the web of community loyalty, and hidden truths began to surface.
Ep 1:
A Scream in the Marsh
A desperate 911 call and a chilling marsh discovery unravel into five bodies, exposing a serial killer hidden behind Oak Beach's gated paradise.
Ep 2:
The Doctor's Contradictions
Suspicion turns to Dr. Peter Hackett, a prominent neighbor whose shifting stories and mysterious phone call to a grieving mother raise unsettling questions.
Ep 3:
Neighbors Divided, Suspicion Rising
The Scalise family breaks ranks, accusing Hackett of a cover-up and building a disturbing theory about hidden bodies and a community's complicity.
Ep 4:
Tracing a Killer's Routes
Amateur sleuths trace Hackett's commuting routes to scattered remains across Long Island, building a chilling psychological and geographic case against him.
Ep 5:
No Answers, No Justice
As Hackett walks free and Mari Gilbert's fight ends in tragedy, the Long Island Killer case closes with haunting, unresolved truths.
Discussions (13)
Mario
Level 3 · 9 mo agoHackett denying that call is proper shady behavior
Todd
Level 6 · 9 mo agoHackett is a narcissist to the core. Inserting himself into the case just to feel important is sick.
Ryan
Level 5 · 9 mo agoPhone records confirm he called. He is a liar.
